The Narrative Spine: Coordinating Communications Across Jurisdictions in Complex Disputes

Disputes are no longer fought the way they once were. We have long since entered a hyper-globalised world, where capital, supply chains, data and even reputations cross borders as a matter of course — jumping over language barriers and physical borders that mankind has built and has not yet managed to dismantle. What does this mean for litigation? A commercial conflict that would once have played out before one court and one national press now unfolds simultaneously across several legal systems, media markets and political arenas — each moving at its own pace, and by its own rules.

This is, above all, a call for local expertise. Every international dispute contains ingredients — a court’s sensitivities, a market’s media law, a regulator’s habits, a public debate already underway — that can only be read and handled correctly with a local eye when much is at stake. The do’s and don’ts can vary strongly even between seemingly closely connected markets such as Austria, Switzerland and Germany, which share much of their media landscape.

Misread one of these markets, and one of the pillars on which successful cross-jurisdictional work rests falls apart.

Most organisations nonetheless respond to this complexity in one of two flawed ways. Either they centralise — one headquarters-approved narrative, deployed identically everywhere — or they translate, treating local adaptation as a purely linguistic exercise. Both fail for the same reason: they assume the environments are comparable, even when they are not.

The result is that litigation remains an undermanaged asset for most corporates. Even the best global law firms tend to see only the legal dimension of an international dispute; they often lack the media and communications angle that runs alongside it.

Four Environments to Consider

From my experience, four dimensions matter most when facing an international dispute.

Media environments operate under different legal and cultural constraints from market to market. In some jurisdictions, active litigation is legitimate news, and parties are expected to litigate in public to some degree; in others, this is handled with far more restraint. Knowing the local customs is key to engaging professionally and staying in control of the narrative.

Stakeholder environments carry different weight in different places. In one market, the decisive audience is institutional investors; in another, a works council, a licensing authority, or a single controlling family may have far more influence over the outcome — and none at all elsewhere. Stakeholders are often where corporate Realpolitik plays out in practice: employees, customers, banks and business partners weigh the same statement differently depending on which filter they read it through. The announcement that satisfies investor relations in one market can, filtered through a different stakeholder set elsewhere, read as the closure of a production site.

Regulatory environments shape not only what may be said, but what may be written at all. The treatment of communications advisers under privilege varies dramatically: structures that protect strategy documents in one legal system offer no protection in another, and anything drafted anywhere may become disclosable somewhere. Disclosure regimes — and how they affect non-legal advisers, not just lawyers — need to be vetted as part of the litigation strategy, not treated as an afterthought.

Political environments determine how a dispute is framed beyond the courtroom, and beyond the immediate issue at hand. What local political debates need to be factored into the communications strategy? In today’s populist climate, a foreign investor is always at risk of being used as a political instrument by an opposition party, and a counterparty may be locally well placed to build narratives that damage your client’s position. This needs to be analysed case by case, market by market.

One Strategy Is Not One Message

The answer to this complexity is not fragmentation — fragment the response, and you risk losing control of it entirely. A dispute communicated through unconnected local campaigns will, sooner or later, produce contradictions and tensions between markets. Worse, those inconsistencies can become evidence used against you if the case turns adversarial. Opposing counsel and investigators both read across borders, and contradictions between markets are among the first things they look for.

What holds a cross-border strategy together is best understood as a narrative spine: the single, agreed factual position of what the case is actually about. One of my late mentors, Alan Hilburg, framed the test simply:

“What are we solving for?”

That spine is fixed centrally and anchored in the legal arguments. Everything else — local nuance, timing, channels, spokespersons, and even the decision whether to say anything at all — is decided locally, in close coordination with the project lead.

Maintaining that distinction takes real, ongoing work. It means the German statement and the London statement can differ substantially in tone, length and emphasis while remaining strictly consistent on substance. It means silence in one market can be a legitimate strategic choice even while another market requires active engagement. And it means that when a statement travels — as it will, because filings get quoted, wires syndicate internationally, and a line published in one market can become a headline in another within hours — constant cross-market awareness has to be maintained.

Where Local Judgment Really Counts

Certain decisions cannot be made from headquarters, however capable the central team, because they depend on knowledge that is nearly impossible to export: which journalists actually shape opinion on a given subject in a given market, and which merely appear to; what ‘off the record’ and ‘on background’ mean in practice under local convention, which differs more between markets than most executives assume. In the end, communications is — still — a people’s business.

How a specific court, regulator or ministry has historically responded to public commentary on its own proceedings is another such judgment call. These calls require experience, not just information — and they are the reason cross-border dispute communications is fundamentally a coordination discipline built on genuine local expertise.

The Case for Coordinated Local Expertise

My experience across cross-border disputes points to one conclusion. The organisations that navigate multi-jurisdictional disputes well are not those with the largest central function, nor the most disciplined global messaging. They are those that combine a firmly held narrative spine with practitioners who genuinely know their own markets — its media law, its journalists, its regulators, its politics — connected by a coordination architecture that ties them together.

That is the model the Crisis & Litigation Communicators’ Alliance is built on: senior local specialists, each in their own jurisdiction, working to one strategy.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the position of CLCA or all its member firms.

 

Reputation Is an Asset – Treat It Like One Before Litigation Starts

“We have a case starting in the High Court next week and a journalist has asked for a comment – what should I say?” is a line destined to cause frustration and amusement among litigation PR practitioners in equal measure. Frustration because there is so much to learn about a client, topic and their circumstances that an immediate media response cannot convey. Amusement because the client, their marketing department, in-house counsel, external legal advisor and, in London at least, their barrister, will have known about this progressing litigation for at least 18 months, but none seem to have considered the reputational aspects during this time.

For most litigants, bringing or facing a legal claim is one of the most uncomfortable moments in their commercial or personal lives. The costs can be eye-watering, plus there’s an added risk of bearing some of the other side’s costs, and damages, if you lose. The management hours required to present a case fully and accurately can be severely disruptive to the day-to-day business – and all of this comes before the reputational liability is even considered.

Yet reputation should be treated as much of an asset class as a company’s sales and investments with regards to the bottom line. It merits goodwill accounting entries and helps secure lower borrowing costs, let alone attracting clients and staff loyalty. Brands can take years to establish, yet a badly managed litigation PR strategy can swiftly cause a serious dent to that reputation. In short, paying scant attention to how a claim might play out in the public sphere or how to rebut damaging allegations from the other side during proceedings, is akin to tearing up £50 notes and leaving the outcome to fate.

Any litigation PR adviser worth their salt would assess the prospective client’s case several months before trial, certainly by the point at which the particulars of claim have been filed and served. Some clients prefer to bring PRs on board even sooner, during the pre-action stage, so the strategic comms team is fully briefed on the issues at stake and the potential rebuttal and can consider the narrative behind the claim before it is filed. This allows for briefings to media on behalf of a claimant even before the defendant knows the case exists – positioning the claimant’s narrative from the outset.

One of the crucial roles of a litigation PR adviser is assessing the context in which the claim arises. Has the defendant faced similar lawsuits in the past, or been sued on unrelated matters at considerable cost to their business? Are they known to settle ahead of trial, or might they show greater resilience in the face of sustained media exposure? Has there been much litigation activity in the sector as a whole? Is this case likely to set a legal precedent, and therefore attract its own publicity, no matter the judgment? Could the outcome trigger an existential crisis for either party?

Considerations apply to the potential stakeholders and audiences impacted by the litigation. These might include employees, key clients, bankers and insurers, suppliers, landlords, members of parliament, local officials, competitors, future employees, and acquisition targets, as well as overseas markets where relevant. Each of these groups requires a dedicated set of narratives to explain, reassure and contextualise the litigation challenge. The PR adviser should anticipate the needs of each and spend time drafting and stress-testing language and positioning to ensure they hit the mark. These drafts must be checked with the legal team, to ensure nothing is said or even intimated that could appear contrary to how the case is being presented in court. The PR must also weigh which of these audiences, if any, should be briefed before any media coverage of the case, and which only once the matter becomes public. This detailed preparation takes time and requires careful consideration by experienced advisers.

Managing reputations during times of litigation is not limited to considering those messages your client would like to convey, but also should incorporate how best to handle incoming negative storytelling either planted by the other side or coming from a hostile media. There are times when these unhelpful or misleading stories should be challenged on the record, and other times when silence can help limit the damage, and clients should resist the urge to add oxygen to the flame of publicity. An experienced litigation PR adviser understands these nuances and works with your legal team to maintain corporate credibility throughout this period of intense commercial challenge.

The overall lesson is simple: reputation is too valuable an asset to leave to chance once litigation looms. Engage a litigation PR adviser early – ideally at the pre-action stage – so that narrative, rebuttal and stakeholder strategy are in place before the first headline, not scrambled together after it appears. Where a dispute crosses borders, make sure such experienced support extends across every relevant jurisdiction, so your messaging holds firm and is consistent in each market where your commercial and/or personal reputation is at stake. The cost of getting this right is modest against the brand value it protects. Conversely, the cost of getting it wrong can be measured in those pesky £50 notes.

Melanie Riley, Managing Director, Head of Litigation PR, Bell Yard Kysen Communications

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the position of CLCA or all its member firms.

Crisis and Litigation Communicators Alliance launches new Network Partnership Model

The Crisis and Litigation Communicators Alliance (CLCA) is proud to announce the launch of its new Network Partnership model, a strategic initiative aimed at expanding collaboration within the crisis and litigation support ecosystem.

This Network Partnership opens up membership opportunities for non-PR firms, that are integral to the wider ecosystem of crisis and litigation communication. This initiative allows eligible firms to engage and collaborate directly with CLCA’s global member organizations, fostering an environment of cooperation and shared expertise.

Through this initiative, eligible firms will gain direct access to CLCA’s global network, allowing them to engage with top-tier litigation PR and crisis communication professionals across multiple jurisdictions. This collaboration will not only enhance the capabilities of existing members but also strengthen the field of crisis and litigation support as a whole.

Interested firms are encouraged to reach out to Henrik Hierl at office@clc-alliance.com for more details on how to become a Network Partner.

About CLCA 

The Crisis and Litigation Communicators Alliance (CLCA) is a global network of owner-managed PR consulting firms who are each leaders in the areas of Crisis Management and Strategic Legal communications in their respective markets. Clients can benefit from the collaboration of members on cross-border matters and the CLCA’s specialist expertise in international disputes (especially competition law and cartel cases, cross-border litigation, class actions, regulatory enforcement cases, fraud and employment related disputes).

Our constituent firms can be found here. For membership enquiries in jurisdictions not already covered, please contact chairperson@CLC-Alliance.org

iCorporate joins the CLC Alliance as exclusive member for Italy

 

The Crisis and Litigation Communicators Alliance (CLCA) is proud to announce iCorporate as its new Italian member.

“We are very proud to announce the membership of iCorporate in CLCA, a network that groups together some of the most important communication consultancy firms in the world, specialized in crisis and litigation management,” comments Francesco Foscari, Executive Chairman of iCorporate.

Founded in Milan in 2013, iCorporate is a consultancy company specialized in corporate, economic-financial, sustainability, and crisis communication. The company was established with the awareness that integrating traditional PR with digital communication is key to effective corporate reputation management. Today, it is led by President Francesco Foscari and CEO Andrea Gaudenzi and consists of around 30 professionals with extensive experience, multidisciplinary skills, and young talents.

“Italy has long been a priority for the CLCA, as one of Europe’s largest economies. We have taken our time to find the right partner, and we are very pleased to welcome iCorporate into the alliance. Their deep expertise, professionalism, and experience in high-profile and sensitive cases will be a great asset to our international network.” said Martin Jenewein, Chairperson of the CLC Alliance and Senior Partner at the Viennese Litigation PR agency SMJ Partners.

“This partnership represents for us not only the opportunity to be able to work on cross-border issues, but above all to confront and cooperate with those who are the most qualified and reputed professionals at international level. iCorporate’s long experience in managing often complex and highly relevant crises has enabled the CLCA network to see in us solid and high-profile interlocutors for such a specialized and sensitive activity.” Concluded Francesco Foscari.

About the CLCA

The Crisis and Litigation Communicators ́Alliance (CLCA) is a global network of owner-managed PR consulting firms who are each leaders in the areas of Crisis Management and Strategic Legal communications in their respective markets. Clients can benefit from the collaboration of members on cross-border matters and the CLCA’s specialist expertise in international disputes (especially competition law and cartel cases, cross-border litigation, class actions, regulatory enforcement cases, fraud and employment related disputes).

Our constituent firms can be found here. For membership enquiries in jurisdictions not already covered, please contact chairperson@CLC-Alliance.org

Apollo Strategists bring the CLCA to Luxembourg.

The Crisis and Litigation Communicators’ Alliance (CLCA) continues its growth and welcomes Apollo Strategists as its newest member, expanding the network’s presence to Luxembourg.

“Joining CLCA is an opportunity for Apollo Strategists to engage in a forward-thinking community at the crossroads of law and reputation. We look forward to contributing Luxembourg’s perspective to the network, while also learning from peers across jurisdictions to refine and elevate our approach to litigation communications.” Says Pascale Kaufmann,

Founder and Managing Director, Apollo Strategist

Apollo Strategists is Luxembourg’s first PR, litigation, and public affairs advisory company, headquartered in Luxembourg City. As an independent firm, it specializes in strategic communications, public affairs, crisis communications, and litigation PR. Created in 2012, Apollo combines the expertise of an international network with a detailed understanding and experience of the local market.

Apollo has a broad portfolio of (listed) international and local clients, including global technology, financial and industrial companies, as well as foundations, associations, and governmental organizations. The firm advises company owners, business leaders, and boards of directors at a strategic level. Apollo Strategists has strong expertise in the financial and industrial fields—covering sectors such as aviation and space, energy, healthcare, biotech and pharma, IT and (Fin)tech, automotive, and public transport—serving both public and private organizations.

“Luxembourg is a central hub for finance, policy, and global business, and Apollo brings both deep sectoral expertise and a reputation for strategic excellence. We are very pleased to welcome them into our international alliance.” said Martin Jenewein, Chairperson of the CLC Alliance and Senior Partner at the Viennese Litigation PR agency SMJ Partners. “

Apollo Strategists will also participate in the CLCA’s upcoming annual meeting, taking place this May in New York, where members from across the globe will gather to exchange insights and strengthen cross-border collaboration.

About CLCA

The Crisis and Litigation Communicators’ Alliance (CLCA) is a global network of owner-managed PR consulting firms, each a leader in the areas of crisis management and strategic legal communications in their respective markets. Clients benefit from the collaboration of members on cross-border matters and CLCA’s specialist expertise in international disputes—especially competition law and cartel cases, cross-border litigation, class actions, regulatory enforcement cases, fraud, and employment-related disputes.

Our constituent firms can be found here. For membership enquiries in jurisdictions not already covered, please contact chairperson@CLC-Alliance.org.

Crisis & Litigation Communicators’ Alliance (CLCA)

21 Fleet Street, London EC4Y 1AA

www.clc-alliance.com / contact@clc-alliance.com